PSOrvia

Learn · PSOrvia Player

Louder is not better: loudness and dynamics

You hear the same piece quiet, louder and heavily compressed, and you learn why you may only compare sounds at equal loudness and what dynamics are.

Difficulty
medium
Duration
approx. 10 minutes
You need
PSOrvia Player

The audio example at the end

This is what the final state sounds like. Below it you can download the file in lossless form.

The audio example at the end

0:00

Keyboard: Space plays or pauses, arrow keys jump 5 seconds, Home and End go to start and end.

Lossless (FLAC)

The ear almost always takes the louder one to be better. That is why in a comparison the sound that is only a few decibels higher in level often wins. Loudness measures how loud a piece arrives in the ear (according to ITU-R BS.1770, in LUFS). Dynamics is the distance between quiet and loud passages. Anyone who wants to make a piece louder without overloading it compresses it with a compressor and thereby takes dynamics away. Here you hear the same piece in five states. Unlike in the other guides, they are deliberately not equally loud; the loudness is given at every step.

Headphones or speakers at moderate volume: one audio example is clearly louder than the first. The peaks of all examples stay below −1 dBTP, nothing is overloaded.

For comparison

Starting point: quiet, with a lot of dynamics

0:00

Keyboard: Space plays or pauses, arrow keys jump 5 seconds, Home and End go to start and end.

  1. Step 1: Just louder

    The starting point has a loudness of about −23 LUFS and leaves a lot of room. In the first step it is just made louder, by about 5 dB, nothing else changes. Listen closely: many people take this version to be “better”, yet it is the same music. That is why you should only compare versions at equal loudness.

    Audio example

    The same sound, clearly louder. The rise from the quiet to the loud bars is preserved.

    The “Level” view shows both curves over time; the line below states by how many dB the second sound is louder on average.

    Step 1: Just louder

    0:00

    Keyboard: Space plays or pauses, arrow keys jump 5 seconds, Home and End go to start and end.

    Dynamic value dialog in the player with the dynamic value by the DR method, loudness range in LU and album value for the dynamic original
    The track menu “Dynamic value …” for the original: dynamic value, loudness range and the album value.
  2. Step 2: Heavily compressed: loud, but flat

    Now the piece is brought to about −12 LUFS with a compressor and a limiter, without overloading. The quiet passages rise, the loud ones are held back, and the distance between them, the dynamics, shrinks. In the player, the track menu shows under “Dynamic range …” the dynamic range value of a track and its loudness range. The smaller both values are, the flatter the piece.

    In the player
    Track menu (right-click or “More”)Titelmenü

    Audio example

    The piece is loud and dense. The build-up from the quiet first bar to the loud last bar is almost gone; everything pushes equally hard the whole time.

    In the “Level” view the envelope shrinks: before, it rises over four bars, after, it lies almost flat at the top.

    Step 2: Heavily compressed: loud, but flat

    0:00

    Keyboard: Space plays or pauses, arrow keys jump 5 seconds, Home and End go to start and end.

    Dynamic value dialog in the player with the dynamic value by the DR method, loudness range in LU and album value for the heavily compressed version
    The same dialog for the heavily compressed version: dynamic value and loudness range are clearly smaller.
  3. Step 3: Listening at equal loudness

    The heavily compressed version is lowered back to −23 LUFS, as loud as the starting point. That is exactly what “Match loudness” in “Listen for approval” (Settings › Extras) does: the player measures each version according to ITU-R BS.1770 and lowers the louder ones to the quietest, so that the louder one does not win just because of its volume. Compare this version with the starting point: now you hear what the compression cost.

    In the player
    Settings › Extras › Listen for approvalan

    Audio example

    As loud as the starting point, but without its build-up: all bars sound almost equally strong.

    The “Level” view shows the jump downward and that the curve stays flat: the volume is the same as at the start again, the dynamics are not. With “Wiper” you drag a dividing line across the spectrograms.

    Step 3: Listening at equal loudness

    0:00

    Keyboard: Space plays or pauses, arrow keys jump 5 seconds, Home and End go to start and end.

    Listening review in the player with two versions as waveforms one above the other and the switches Loop and Match loudness
    “Listening review” with two versions as waveforms; “Match loudness” is switched on.
  4. Step 4: Equally loud, but livelier: gently compressed

    A gentle compression (ratio 2.5 to 1) with the same loudness as the starting point (−23 LUFS): level and tone color stay, only the dynamics get a little smaller, but the build-up stays audible. In the player, under Settings › Sound you set “Volume leveling” to “Off”, “Per track” or “Per album”; the player then matches the volume of the pieces during playback without touching their dynamics.

    In the player
    Settings › Sound › Volume levelingJe Titel

    Audio example

    As loud as the starting point and almost the same sound; the quiet and loud bars are just a little closer together.

    Start with “Level”: the envelope is on average as high as before, only the peaks are flatter. “Difference” shows that the spectrum stays almost the same.

    Step 4: Equally loud, but livelier: gently compressed

    0:00

    Keyboard: Space plays or pauses, arrow keys jump 5 seconds, Home and End go to start and end.

    Player settings, Sound page, with the rotary switch Volume leveling set to Per track
    Settings › Sound in the player with the control “Volume leveling” (Off, Per track, Per album).

Listening quiz

Can you hear which step is behind it? Listen to the three sounds and choose the one that belongs to the named step. None of this is saved. Caution: one sound is very loud.

1. Which sound is the heavily compressed version after step 2?

2. Which sound belongs to step 3, the matched version?

3. Which sound is the gently compressed version after step 4, equally loud as the starting point?

Continue